When it comes to nostalgic candy that stirs fond memories of childhood and Idaho's sweet heritage, the Idaho Candy Company reigns supreme. Their lineup of timeless treats, like the potato-shaped Idaho Spud Bar and nutty Old Faithful Bar, has delighted generations since 1901. Now, this Boise icon is up for recognition in the 2025 Boise Favorites contest by the Idaho Statesman, nominated in the "Best Candy Store" category—a testament to its enduring appeal as a source of nostalgic candy. With voting open through October 20, 2025, at voteboisefavorites.com, fans can cast their ballot to celebrate Idaho Candy Company's role in preserving Boise's flavorful past. Whether you're craving a taste of yesteryear or gifting a box of history, their nostalgic candy is the ultimate way to savor the Gem State's charm.
Celebrating a Century of Nostalgic Candy Excellence
The Idaho Statesman's Boise Favorites contest, now in its third year, invites the Treasure Valley community to nominate and vote for local gems across categories like dining, shopping, and entertainment. Idaho Candy Company's nomination in "Best Candy Store" highlights its status as a beloved staple, where nostalgic candy isn't just sold—it's crafted with recipes dating back over 100 years. From the fluffy marshmallow centers of early 20th-century bars to the buttery crunch of toffee, each piece evokes the simplicity of door-to-door sales in 1901 Boise. This recognition comes at a perfect time, as the company—recently acquired by the Sturdivant family in July 2025—continues to blend tradition with fresh appeal, producing about 17 million nostalgic candy pieces annually.
Voting for Boise Favorites runs until October 20, giving nostalgic candy lovers a chance to show support for the treats that have sweetened Idaho lives for generations. Past winners have included local legends in food and retail, and with community buzz building on social media, Idaho Candy Company's nomination underscores its place in Boise's heart. Cast your vote today and help crown them Boise's favorite spot for nostalgic candy that tastes like home.
Iconic Nostalgic Candy Treats That Earned the Nomination
Idaho Candy Company's nomination shines a light on its portfolio of nostalgic candy, each with a story as rich as its flavors. The Idaho Spud Bar, born in 1918, features a cocoa-marshmallow center coated in dark chocolate and coconut—a playful nod to Idaho's potato fame that's been a bestseller for over a century. Then there's the Old Faithful Bar from 1925, with vanilla marshmallow, whole peanuts, and milk chocolate, inspired by Yellowstone's geyser for a reliable burst of joy.
Rounding out the classics is the Cherry Cocktail Bar (1926), blending a maraschino cherry center with peanuts and milk chocolate for a tart, nutty escape reminiscent of Prohibition-era speakeasies. These nostalgic candy staples, joined by modern additions like Huckleberry Gems (2012), showcase why the company deserves your vote—they're not just sweets, but slices of Idaho history.
Vote for Nostalgic Candy Magic in Boise Favorites
Idaho Candy Company's nomination in the 2025 Boise Favorites contest is a sweet reminder of its impact on local nostalgia. As voting heats up through October 20, head to voteboisefavorites.com to support the nostalgic candy that has defined Boise bites for generations. Follow the fun on Idaho Candy Company Instagram for updates, and snag your favorites from idahospud.com—because nothing says Idaho like a mouthful of history. Vote today and keep the nostalgic candy legacy alive!